Skip to content
BuyVotesForContest
Ask a question

Readers' choice awards and removed votes: what published rules name

In short The published rules of a readers' choice award are the place to look for a clause on bought votes, and the rules cited here name automated means, fraudulent means and a payment or other incentive. USA TODAY's readers' choice rules disqualify votes produced by a script, a macro or any other automated means, and Metroland Media Group, which runs a Readers' Choice programme, decides its winners by the total votes each business receives per category.

Published · Rules last checked · BuyVotesForContest

Metroland Media Group decides Readers' Choice winners by total votes, ranked when voting ends

In the Readers' Choice programme that Metroland Media Group runs, a business is placed by the total of its votes within its category, and the finalists are ranked when the voting period ends. Beyond the count, the conditions an organiser publishes for entries and votes can lead it to correct or void a result that breaks them.

In USA TODAY's readers' choice rules, the method that produced a vote decides whether it counts

The ground that USA TODAY's readers' choice rules name is the way a vote was generated, whether by script, macro or other automated means, and the stated consequence is disqualification of that vote. Where a readers' choice award has such a clause, it belongs to that organiser along with the counter and the log, so the clause is read in that organiser's own rules.

SaaStr and the Lost Ark emote contest name votes obtained through fraud, automation or an incentive

In its rules SaaStr “reserves the right to disregard any votes achieved through automated or fraudulent means and to disqualify the entrant”. The Lost Ark emote contest goes beyond voiding automated votes: it “can disqualify a finalist who uses a payment or another incentive to obtain votes”, so its consequence reaches the finalist and not only the vote.

Of the rules cited here, the Lost Ark emote contest's wording is the one that names a payment or other incentive for votes, while the USA TODAY and SaaStr rules name automated or fraudulent means.

In the Queen's Commonwealth Writing Competition, length alone can end an entry

Not every disqualification concerns votes: in the Queen's Commonwealth Writing Competition, an entry over the 1,000-word cap is disqualified automatically, which is a rule about length. Among essay writing competition tips, the rules that end an entry before a judge reads it include word caps and official entry forms.

Five organisers word their rules on counts and disqualification in different ways

Each contest writes its own penalties for votes and for entries, so the rule of one organiser does not become the rule of another.

What each organiser's wording covers
Organiser and contestWhat the wording coversWhat the wording states
Metroland Media Group, Readers' ChoiceThe countWinners are decided by the total votes each business receives per category
USA TODAY, readers' choiceAutomated votesProhibited, and such votes are disqualified
SaaStrVotes by automated or fraudulent meansThe organiser may disregard them and disqualify the entrant
Lost Ark emote contestA payment or another incentive to obtain votesA finalist who uses one can be disqualified
Queen's Commonwealth Writing CompetitionThe length of an entryEntries over 1,000 words are disqualified automatically

A vote total sits beneath the rules that the organiser has published

Readers who want to buy contest votes should first read which votes the organiser's published rules count. A vote total cannot overturn a rule that the organiser published, and it cannot reopen a window that has closed.

In readers' choice awards results, the Metroland programme decides winners by the total votes each business receives per category, and what counts as contest votes within the rules is for the organiser's published rules to say.

  • Find the clause on automated votes and see which means it names.
  • Look for any clause that mentions an incentive offered in return for votes.
  • See whether the clause says votes are disregarded or voided, or the entry is disqualified.
  • Note when the ranking is taken, since Metroland ranks finalists at the end of the voting period.
  • Return any question to the organiser, whose published rules govern the result.

Questions and answers

Can an entry be disqualified over bought votes in a readers' choice award?

Where a published rule provides for it, yes: the Lost Ark emote contest names a finalist who uses an incentive to obtain votes, a ground that goes beyond the automated votes named in the USA TODAY readers' choice rules. A readers' choice award has such a clause only if its own rules say so, which is why the rules come before any assumption.

What happens to votes generated by a script or macro?

USA TODAY's readers' choice rules prohibit them and disqualify them, the Lost Ark emote contest voids them, and the SaaStr rules reserve the right to disregard them. The consequence is set by each organiser, so the rules of the award concerned are the text to read.

When does Metroland rank the finalists in a Readers' Choice category?

The ranking comes at the close of the voting period, and Metroland takes each finalist's vote count at that moment. A lead earlier in the cycle is therefore provisional, because the ranking that decides the result is taken once, at the close.

Who decides whether votes are removed from a count?

Removal is the organiser's call: the count, the record of votes and the disqualification clause sit with it, and its published rules are where any consequence of a breach is set. A reader who needs the exact clause asks that organiser for it, since a summary of the clause is not the clause.

Is every disqualification about votes?

No: the Queen's Commonwealth Writing Competition disqualifies entries over its 1,000-word cap automatically, which concerns length and not votes. An organiser can write a disqualification into its own terms for a specific breach, as that competition does for length, and its rule is automatic and not a deduction.

The votes we bring come from advertising channels that reach real people and do not break the contest's rules. Before a launch, we go through that contest's published rules and compare the channels with them. Buy contest votes

For a readers' choice award, the organiser's published rules are the place to read which votes count and what follows for a vote that breaks them, and the decision stays with that organiser.

BuyVotesForContest explains how contests are judged and what their published rules allow.