Disqualification after voting closes: what published rules say
In short Two of the published rules quoted here name purchase or payment in connection with contest votes, and none of the rules quoted says whether an entry can be disqualified for bought votes after voting has closed. The consequences that these rules name fall on three different things: the votes, the finalist or entrant, and the entry itself.
Published · Rules last checked · BuyVotesForContest
Two organisers' rules treat automated votes as votes to be disqualified or left uncounted
The readers' choice rules of USA TODAY disqualify any vote produced by a script, a macro or some other automated means, which places the consequence on the votes themselves. The competition run on The Open Act takes the same line with a different verb: it states that “robotic or automated voting mechanisms are not accepted, and such votes will not be counted”. In both cases the consequence falls on the votes. A separate playbook on how to get contest votes within the rules covers the ways of gathering support that organisers permit.
SaaStr and the Lost Ark emote contest void or disregard votes from automated or fraudulent means
The Lost Ark emote contest voids votes that come from automated means or from vote-swapping sites, and its rules reach the finalist as well, who can be disqualified. SaaStr's sweepstakes rules name the entrant too: SaaStr “reserves the right to disregard any votes achieved through automated or fraudulent means and to disqualify the entrant”. Both rules reach the person, not only the vote.
The Chicago Tribune's contest placed tasting after the vote close and disqualifies copied entries
In the Chicago Tribune's 2026 holiday cookie contest, reader voting closed at 11:59 p.m. on October 23, and the contest put tasting by guest judges after that close. The vote selected the twelve recipes that advanced to tasting, so a stage of the contest followed the close of voting.
The Tribune also asks for the entrant's own recipe and disqualifies an entry that reproduces another person's published work, a ground that rests on the content of the entry and not on a count. A separate page on baking contest winning recipes covers the vote-and-taste format of that contest.
The quoted rules put the consequence on the votes, on the finalist or entrant, or on the entry
The table sorts the organisers named above by what each consequence falls on, with the conduct that each rule names beside it.
| Organiser and rule | Conduct the rule names | What the consequence falls on |
|---|---|---|
| USA TODAY, readers' choice rules | Votes produced by a script, a macro or some other automated means | The votes, which are disqualified |
| The Open Act, competition rules | Robotic or automated voting mechanisms | The votes, which are not counted |
| Lost Ark emote contest | Automated means and vote-swapping sites; paying or offering another incentive to obtain votes | The votes, which are voided; the finalist, who can be disqualified |
| SaaStr, sweepstakes rules | Votes achieved through automated or fraudulent means | The votes, which can be disregarded; the entrant, who can be disqualified |
| Chicago Tribune, 2026 holiday cookie contest | An entry that copies another person's published work | The entry, which is disqualified |
An entry can check what the rules name, whom they sanction and when they apply
The quoted rules leave three points to look up in the terms of the contest that an entry has joined: the conduct that the organiser names, the thing on which the consequence falls, and any statement of when the organiser may apply it. A reader who wants to buy contest votes should first read which votes the contest rules count. A separate page of essay writing competition tips sets out how judges score entries and what gets an entry thrown out. The decision stays with the organiser's published rules.
- Look in the voting clause for the conduct that the organiser names, whether automated means, fraudulent means, a payment or another incentive.
- Note whether the consequence falls on the votes, on the finalist or entrant, or on the entry itself.
- Check whether the rules say when a consequence may be applied, since the closing date of the voting window is a different thing from that.
Questions and answers
Do contest rules allow you to buy votes?
That depends on the organiser's own rules, and The Open Act competition names purchase on both sides of its voting. Eligible voters in that competition may add votes for one or more competitors by purchase, and “competitors are not permitted to purchase votes for themselves”.
Can a vote total overturn a published rule?
No: a vote is a single number attached to one entry, so it cannot overturn a rule the organiser published or extend a window that has closed. The Queen's Commonwealth Writing Competition shows the point with a length rule: an entry over its 1,000-word cap is disqualified automatically.
Do the contest rules of USA TODAY and SaaStr name bought votes?
USA TODAY's readers' choice rules name votes produced by a script, a macro or some other automated means, and SaaStr's sweepstakes rules name votes achieved through automated or fraudulent means, so neither wording, as quoted here, names payment. Their stated consequences differ: USA TODAY disqualifies such votes, while SaaStr reserves the right to disqualify the entrant as well.
Can bought votes get an entry disqualified?
In one case among the rules quoted, yes: the Lost Ark emote contest “can disqualify a finalist who uses a payment or another incentive to obtain votes”. That wording attaches the consequence to the finalist, and the organiser of the contest decides how it applies.
The votes we bring come from advertising channels that reach real people and do not break the contest's rules. Before a launch, we go through that contest's published rules and compare the channels with them. Buy contest votes
For a contest, the organiser's published rules are the place to read which votes count and what follows for the rest, so read the voting clause before relying on a summary of it.
BuyVotesForContest explains how contests are judged and what their published rules allow.
Sources
- Get Contest Votes Within the Rules: A Playbook · BuyVotesForContest
- Baking Contest Winning Recipes: The Playbook for Vote-and-Taste Contests · BuyVotesForContest
- Essay writing competition tips: what judges score and what throws entries out · BuyVotesForContest